Wednesday, August 18, 2010

Displaced Persons

In May 1945, Pavel Mandl, a Polish Jew recently liberated from a concentration camp, lands near a displaced persons camp in the British occupation zone of newly defeated Germany. Alone, possessing nothing but a map, a few tins of food, a toothbrush, and his identity papers, he must scrape together a new life in a chaotic community of refugees, civilians, and soldiers.
Gifted with a talent for black-market trading, Pavel soon procures clothing, false documents, and a modest house, where he installs himself and a pair of fellow refugees—Fela, a young widow who fled Poland for Russia at the outset of the war, and Chaim, a resourceful teenage boy whose smuggling skills have brought him to the Western zones. The trio soon form a makeshift family, searching for surviving relatives, railing against their circumscribed existence, and dreaming of visas to America.
Fifteen years later, haunted by decisions they made as "DPs," Pavel and Fela are married and living in Queens with their young son and daughter, and Chaim has recently emigrated from Israel with his wife, Sima. Pavel opens a small tailoring shop with his scheming brother-in-law while Fela struggles to establish peace in a loosely traditional household; Chaim and Sima adapt cheerfully to American life and its promise of freedom from a brutal past. Their lives are no longer dominated by the need to endure, fight, hide, or escape. Instead, they grapple with past trauma in everyday moments: taking the children to the municipal pool, shopping for liquor, arguing with landlords.

For decades, Pavel, Fela, and Chaim battle over memory and identity on the sly, within private groups of survivors. But as the Iron Curtain falls in the 1990s, American society starts to embrace the tragedy as a cultural commodity, and survivor politics go public. Clever and stubborn, tyrannical and generous, Pavel, Fela, and Chaim articulate the self-conscious strivings of an immigrant community determined to write its own history, on its own terms.

My take: Unfortunately, my expectations were different than the book.  The story of finding a place in a world where you are not wanted is fascinating.  Pavel et. al somehow find ways to make due.  They live in a house, offer shelter to some, have babies, lose fortunes, start businesses, and get old.

The main problem I had with the book is the style of writing.  I never really knew who was speaking and who the speaker was speaking to.  Quotation marks are not used, at least in the first part of the book and I ended up getting frustrated and experiencing whiplash from trying to figure out what was going on.

I did not finish the book.  I skimmed it and read the ending. I felt hollow and unfulfilled.

2 stars

1 comment:

CountessLaurie said...

Is it a true story? Such potential with the topic...

Thanks for the review.